GM Garth Snow's play-in is a terrible idea
By: Ryan Dadoun
Although the focus of this year's general manager meetings in Florida was headshots, it wasn't the only thing discussed. For example, Islanders' GM Garth Snow made a proposal which would essentially render the regular season meaningless. His idea? Have the eighth through 15th seed teams participate in a single-elimination "play-in" tournament at the end of the tournament to determine who gets the final playoff seed. In other words, despite the fact that Edmonton has stunk all season, they should still be able to make the playoffs over Calgary or Detroit if they have a lucky weekend.
The playoffs, as they are right now, are fine. The NHL has been on fire in the past for having a nearly pointless regular season, but that's no longer the case. It's not easy to make the playoffs anymore, just ask Toronto or Florida. That gives the regular season some credibility. The fact that these 82 games have consequences and losers is the reason fans tune in or buy tickets.
Snow's logic may be that elimination games are fun and therefore this tournament will attract an audience, and the truth is it probably will. But for every fan that watches a game in Snow's "play-in" tournament, two fewer will watch a regular season game. People will see what's happening, shrug, and say, "I'll start watching hockey in April when the games actually matter."
Mercifully, Snow's proposal didn't gain much transaction this time around, but he's not the first to talk about expanding the playoffs and he will not be the last. The temptation to expand the money-making postseason is understandable, but it must be resisted.




