Any hope left for JaMarcus?

It's early in the offseason. We have over two months even before training camp starts. But I've been working at Rotoworld for over three years now and never before seen such consistently poor spring reports as JaMarcus Russell has gotten through late May.
Take a look at SF Chronicle beat writer David White's play-by-play account of Wednesday's spring practice on Twitter. It is ugly. Here are some tweets:
-- jamarcus 1 for 3 in first passing drill, no defense on field
-- jamarcus: 9 of 12 against air so far
-- 7 on 7, jamarcus throws against defense for first time - first pass: hits fargas in shoelaces on 4 yd screen
-- next play; jamarcus misses way wide right in flats screen. yells "s" word. wow. some emotion.
-- next team drills: jamarcus still struggling
-- finally, jamarcus completes something other than screen. over the middle to stewart for 12
-- next pass, way over higgins head, routt with easy pick. not even close
Here is an excerpt from Oakland Tribune writer Jerry McDonald's post-practice report:
Let’s get it out of the way first. JaMarcus Russell’s passing was, well, it was awful.
There’s no other way to put it.
Coach Tom Cable...said Russell was better today than he was Tuesday and he expects him to be better still on Thursday. Would have hated to see Tuesday if he was worse.
Of Russell’s two interceptions, one _ a swing pass which bounced out of the hands of Louis Rankin and to strong side linebacker Jon Alston _ was not his fault. The other sailed well over the head of Johnnie Lee Higgins and was stolen by Stanford Routt.
There was also a near pick in a red zone drill by Kirk Morrison, who dropped the ball. Linebacker Thomas Howard was closer to the play than any intended receiver.
Darrick Brown also dropped a potential interception which was thrown directly to him.
During one 7-on-7 drill, Russell threw four passes, completing one for about two yards to Justin Fargas. The other three passes? One at the feet of Fargas, a slant behind Todd Watkins that was broken up by Hiram Eugene and the Alston interception which bounced off Rankin’s hands.
The Raiders blame it on installing more of a vertical offense, but the terminology is the same and this is Russell's third year in the league. Some blame Russell's "lack of weapons," but good quarterbacks make the receivers around them better. Others blame Russell's rookie-year holdout (as if that's still an issue). Coaching staff turnover certainly hasn't helped, but a good quarterback at least flashes.
Russell hasn't, aside from maybe three games to close out last season. But that's history when Russell doesn't carry it over into the following spring. Russell has serious accuracy issues, mostly stemming from his atrocious footwork.
At what point can we acknowledge that Russell is a bust? When he's benched for Jeff Garcia at midseason? Obviously, no Rotoworld reader is going to take him in their re-draft league, but is anyone still hanging on in dynasty? If you ask Wesseling, Russell is barely even a QB2 for the future.





Comments
I was never a big JaMarcus Russell fan (he has the worst footwork I've ever seen on an NFL QB), but the last 6 games of 2008 provided at the very least a glimmer of hope.
There's no getting around the reports coming out of Oakland though. Would anybody be surprised to see this become a Kerry Collins/Vince Young situation by Week 4?
Posted by: Wess | May 20, 2009 05:31 PM
The same reports said Garcia was just as bad and inaccurate. Everyone needs to calm down. It's easy to hate on JaMarcus for some reason. It's only May.
Posted by: Anonymous | May 20, 2009 06:33 PM
"It's only May?" So what year do you let that excuse go?
If the "some reason" for piling on JaMarbust is the ridiculous money thrown at a prima donna (never played an NFL game but I get to hold the team that drafts me hostage because I'm #1) who has shown NOTHING since Crazy Al first started drooling over him, then feel free to call me out for piling on.
If you WANT the money and WANT the spotlight and WANT the accolades and WANT the ball, then you damn well better be prepared for the cheers/jeers that come your way along with it all.
Posted by: Juggs | May 21, 2009 08:19 AM
you'd have to have a pretty big bench to find room for that wideload
Posted by: veggieb | May 21, 2009 12:56 PM
was he ever rated high? i feel bad for anybody who drafted him all those years ago. i thought he was a bust coming out - or at least overhyped. nothings said otherwise.
Posted by: scott c | May 21, 2009 01:52 PM
was he ever rated high? i think he was the consensus #1 QB coming out the year he did, not simply the raiders' view but darn near everyone.
i've given up claiming that i can predict QB development because it's clear that every NFL scout can't tell either.
Posted by: veggieb | May 21, 2009 05:17 PM
what upsets me is Ja"bust"le is screwing up the rb situation aswell. Two great talents with a decent runner in fargas F%^*ING ging down the toilet.
Posted by: abruzzi | May 25, 2009 08:38 AM