News that won't make Jets fans happy from Mike Lombardi: "Everyone I talk to in and around the NFL feel this job is Schottenheimer’s. He is bright, he is young and he will work with GM Mike Tannenbaum. In the end, the Jets (i.e., Tannenbaum) are more interested in finding someone who will not challenge Mike T.’s power rather than getting the best coach."
I agree with Lombardi that it's not that attractive of a job. The expectations are high, there is no quarterback, and the roster doesn't have a lot of young talent.
Also in that Lombardi article: News that the Cowboys wouldn't seem to mind if Jason Garrett left. How can so much change in a year? Either Jerry Jones misevaluated him them or is misevaluating him now?
The Top-30 Keepers (plus ties!) are finally up.
Chad Pennington is Miami's starter, but I think he will be in a similar situation to Derek Anderson this season. If Miami is more than two games under .500 at any point after midseason, a change will probably be made. It may not be fair, but life's not fair, as Tom Rosenthal always told me.
Troy Aikman would take Eli Manning over Tony Romo. In fantasy, that's an easy call. In reality, to win a game this weekend, I can't believe I'm hesitating. But I'd still take Romo. What say you?
Comments
Romo over Eli in a big game?! Are you serious??
Off the top of my head, I believe Manning has had at least 10 4th quarter comeback wins in his career, including one against the 18-0 Pats in the Superbowl last year. He went on the road during the playoffs last year and won 4 consecutive games, only throwing ONE pick (which hit Steve Smith right in the hands). Conversely, Romo's December record is 5-8, including 0 playoff wins (and 1 fumbled snap).
I'm guessing this is just you going with your gut, which I respect, but I don't even think it's close. I still think Romo is a very good quarterback, and he'll have his share of success, but right now it's a no-brainer. The guy really needs to improve his ball control. I would love to hear what you base your opinion on if you have the time to respond. Thanks.
Posted by: Sam | January 7, 2009 02:39 PM
I too would take Romo.
It would sure be great if we had your advice/rankings for the each week through the rest of the playoff season. You were invaluable during the regular season, and your advice before the start of the wildcard games also did me good--138 points last weekend. In my league we can change players each week so long as we stay under the salary cap.
Posted by: Dave | January 7, 2009 03:22 PM
ima go out on a pretty strong limb and say that carson palmer will eventually need tommy john surgery.
Posted by: scott c | January 7, 2009 04:19 PM
gregg, forget about fantasy for one second - when has romo ever won a big game let alone a playoff game?
this truly is a no brainer - always go sheli in the clutch.
Posted by: tony | January 7, 2009 07:40 PM
Gregg, has the Patriot playoff void caused you to make this awful choice? Romo over Manning in a big game? Who has a Super Bowl? Who beat Romo last year in the playoffs? Manning is better than Romo and he does not have the receivers Romo has.
Posted by: The Bradyless Bunch | January 7, 2009 08:59 PM
I don't see why everyone seems to think Manning is a no-brainer.
Average FF points per game:
Romo 21.6
Manning 15.8
TDs
Romo 26
Manning 21
Passing Yards
Romo 3448
Manning 3238
Total Passing Yards Against Eagles This Year
Romo 495
Manning 314
Posted by: dave | January 7, 2009 10:23 PM
... big games:
Manning - Super Bowl Champ
Romo - ZERO playoff wins
Posted by: Juggs | January 8, 2009 12:11 PM