Randy Moss vs. Jerricho Cotchery
Randy Moss probably isn't going to score 23 touchdowns again this season. His owners are now wondering if he's even going to score ten.
That question was front and center on my mind yesterday when I received an offer in one of my industry leagues: Moss for Jerricho Cotchery. It's a points-per-reception league, and that informed my decision to keep Cotchery. I'd be shocked if Cotchery doesn't catch 85 passes. I wouldn't be shocked if Moss caught only 65. Moss will rebound, and I'd still bet on a top-15 receiver finish. I would make the trade in a standard league, but I'm holding on to the sure thing in Cotchery. How much can change in three weeks!
Let me know if you would do the same thing.
* And to my emailer John: Yes, that means I'd trade Moss for Andre 1500.
Comments
I'd keep Cotchery, not b/c he's that good, but b/c I think MOss will be a dud the rest of the yr.
Would you trade McFadden & J.Stewart for Gore & Engram OR McFadden, J.Stewart, Slaton for Gore and Steve Smith. I'm stacked at RB w/ S.Jackson, Perry, Chris Johnson, Slaton, McFadden & Stewart. I need to trim my RB depth down.
Posted by: Richard A. Leon | September 24, 2008 11:41 AM
I would do that second trade for sure. Still hard to predict how good Stewart will be all year. I'd rather have Gore and Steve Smith.
Posted by: Tenac | September 24, 2008 12:14 PM
Do the Steve Smith trade.
Posted by: Jesse | September 24, 2008 12:32 PM
I'd trade SJax before J-Stew. He's gonna come on. The Rams are a joke.
Perry will also get hurt. Trade him. Stewart's gonna blow it wide open this week.
Posted by: tim | September 24, 2008 12:40 PM
How bout this one Greg-
PPR league -
Cotchery or Burress?
Posted by: Scott L. | September 24, 2008 12:57 PM
Be interesting to see a PPR ranking list.
BTW, the top 200 list still doesn't update right when you post it. The comments above talk about Westbrook moving to rank 5, but he is still listed at #2.
Posted by: Season Passer | September 24, 2008 01:30 PM
The Top 200 doesn't help me because I, too, play in a PPR League. It makes the list rather pointless.
Posted by: Also a Season Passer | September 24, 2008 02:24 PM